Bingowings said:
It's impossible to forgive a mass murdering evil person.
It's possible to forgive a mental ill person who then goes on to work for the evil guys.
The end of the story requires redemption and forgiveness to work.
The redemption works just fine in ROTJ pre 1999 when we knew Vader had done terrible things. Why can't it work in an edit where Vader does terrible things?
Bingowings said:
Keep it as it is and you are keeping a broken characterisation.
We're on the fan edit forum.....why would we be keeping it as it is? :p