logo Sign In

Post #669379

Author
CatBus
Parent topic
'Raiders of the Lost Ark' - bluray and colour timing changes (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/669379/action/topic#669379
Date created
5-Nov-2013, 1:12 PM

Okay, personal reflection and mea culpa time.  I never liked the DVD colors (too blue) and also was dubious of the Blu-ray colors (too gold), although I thought they looked good in spite of my doubts about their authenticity.  Upon seeing the WOWOW screencaps, I was sold that those represented the real deal.

I'd downloaded custom Blu-ray cover art with the correct movie title, and I'd even edited the "scenes from the film" on the back cover so that they matched the WOWOW colors.  Yeah, I was that kinda anal about it, but I love this movie.

I was all set to start a new project where I'd apply HDTV colors to the Blu-ray, splice in the old, darker, opening without the clipped sky detail, and even try to put back the snake reflection from Laserdisc, what the hell.

I browsed those 35mm stills posted elsewhere and thought, "Well, that shows that the gold tint on the Blu-rays was at least partially justified, but look at that sunset, that's still not right.  Maybe I can figure out if there's a happy medium."  So I spent some time in Photoshop doing some color correcting, and... er, well, now I'm convinced even the sunset is probably much closer to correct on the Blu-rays than on WOWOW.  I've done a U-turn and now think the golden hues of the Blu-ray are actually the result of a careful restoration, not a deliberate alteration.

There's still plenty of deliberate alterations on the Blu-ray.  The overly-brightened opening, the missing snake refection, and so on.  But the colors?  Not so much, I'm now convinced.  And I'm afraid I just can't justify doing a whole preservation project to undo such fairly inconsequential things.  So sorry to all, and thanks in particular to Harmy for providing those 35mm stills.  They may have taken a really long time to do it, but they changed at least one mind.