Harmy said:

That I would consider a tragedy. Revisited is great but I really don't think that it should be the version that is viewed a 100 years from now, just as the SE shouldn't be.

There are those that care about film heritage and preservation, and there are those that care about visual continuity (not having a Palpatine that's a woman with monkey eyes in Empire). Me, I care about both. Both the OUT and OT:R should be viewed 100 years from now.

What we can ALL agree on is that it shouldn't be George's SE, which is what he himself wants to happen.