logo Sign In

Post #667873

Author
deepanddark20
Parent topic
Harmy's STAR WARS Despecialized Edition HD - V2.7 - MKV (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/667873/action/topic#667873
Date created
28-Oct-2013, 5:47 PM

I was addressing my original post to Harmy, so now in hindsight I realize that perhaps it should have been a message sent to him directly instead of posted here where it's more public.

HanDuet said:

 the goal of Harmy's Despecialized Edition is not just "to remove 'Special Edition' changes." If it were, then that means we wouldn't be concerned with the additional changes made with the Blu-ray release (which clearly doesn't make sense).

Actually HanDuet, I was using the phrase "Special Edition changes" to mean any change made to the movies from 1997 up to the present. Forgive me for phrasing it that way, but please reread my post with that understanding.

In response to CatBus, I never said I wanted the picture quality to look like watching a VHS tape on a low def tube TV screen. The picture quality of Harmy's edition is actually one of my favorite things about it and I wouldn't want it any lower def than it is (in fact, I'd like it to be even higher def). The higher definition of Harmy's edition is the main reason that I like it so much better than dark_jedi's v3 DVD release. Anything lower def than dark_jedi's release is unwatchable in my opinion. All I'm asking for is a movie that has all the quality of Harmy's edition, except with the words "Episode IV A New Hope" in the opening crawl. I shouldn't need to request that a whole new fan project be started just to make this one little change.

In response to Gogogadget, if you can do that and make it seamless with no loss of any quality, I would adore that.