stretch009 said:

I really like the editions you've made but there's a couple of things I'd like you to consider. The changes you made to ROTJ I like but I can't stand the Special Edition Sarlacc; I'm sure many here would agree.

Most importantly, I think your color correction might be off on all three. You_Too, Adywan, and Harmy (members of this forum) are exceptional at color correction of the movies and maybe they could help you out. Granted I would rather have basic correction on them than have it like the Green shifted Star Wars DE 2.5.

Edit: I'll watch them again and see if I can find anything else you can improve upon.

Thank you for your thoughts. I did very much consider bringing back the original Sarlacc, the only problem I had was that I would have to take the footage from the GOUT and because the Sarlacc footage is not continuous like say Lapti Nek, I thought the change between uprezed DVD footage and HD footage from shot to shot would be too jarring and draw attention to the lower image quality of the uprezed dvd footage. I can certainly give it a try though, see if I can make it work. If only there was HD footage somewhere of that scene with the original Sarlacc...

In terms of colour correction, what would you say is off? Do you feel that a certain colour is too strong? I don't have all the colour reference sources that Harmy has but I did look at many promotional stills taken from the shooting of the films to try to get a feel for the colour of the films.