adywan said:
Sorry, but that doesn't work at all. It changes the emotional impact of the scene. The PT music conveys sadness, almost melodramatic. Not what this scene is about at all. But it does show just how important it is to have the correct piece of music for a scene.
PT is in general melodramatic. At least it happened to Aalenfae and I to realise that while most people thinks that those movies fail to be dark and should be darker, it might be the exact opposite way.
Objectively, there's nothing tragic in a guy falling to the Darkside (PT), but definetely there IS something tragic in discovering that your father is a murderer. So from a certain point of view the OT is the real tragedy of the saga. And the most iconic, the most tragic moment of the saga, which is the one discussed here works perfectly with a dark, menacing qeue, which never happens to sound "tragic", just threatening.
Dark doesn't mean sad. Dark means Evil.
It's good to take note about these details, especially when PT:R is a certain fact in a not so distant future