adywan said:
On another note, it seems a new fan edit is causing me all sorts of headaches...
http://fanedit.org/ifdb/component/content/article/79-fanedit-listings/fanfix/938-star-wars-episode-i-return-of-the-sith-revisited-editionI'm getting numerous messages and emails from people asking me where they can get the edit, why have i done episode 1 before finishing ESB:R, etc etc. I guess they didn't bother to check the editors name before bombarding me with all these questions. lol
I had a notion that this edit by seciors might lead to confusion amongst some, when I read up on it a while back.
I've yet to watch it, but he seems like a talented faneditor, and he's certainly incorporated lots of changes to his 'Episode I' version that I'm interested to see. It was called 'Revisited Edition' because of it being an HD re-do/improvement of an earlier version he released. And for those that don't know, amongst the other edits he's released is one called 'The Abyss:Revisited Edition' and he's planning another called 'Titanic:Revisited Edition' eventually too.
And Monroville's currently stalled 'ALIEN:Revisited' is yet another title that potentially causes confusion.
Thing is, while there's certainly no rule or obligation in fanediting circles to not use 'Revisited' in their edit titles...I just kinda think that it's become so associated with adywan's groundbreaking project, that there *should* be! :)
Despite my mis-givings, I guess imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.