michaelkirschner said:

Adywan made some excellent menus on his Star Wars revisited project I'm sure he wouldn't mind if you copied his menu design exactly

Well, the actual design of the menu isn't the problem - the problem is getting the menu to work, which is much more complicated for BD than it was for DVD. I would be completely satisfied if I could make a DVD type menu - I could totally do without all the bells and whistles that were added for BD, like pop up menu and stuff - I actually have yet to see a single BD menu, that can compete aesthetically with some of the best DVD menus - for example both Star Wars and Lord of the Rings EE BD menus are a disaster compared to their DVD counterparts. I also prefer having several different pages to the menu - like when you go to language selection or chapter selection and the background and music changes from the main menu, rather than having a pop up menu with a united background in one loop under everything, like it usually is on BDs.