Ryan McAvoy said:

imperialscum said:

Bingowings said:

You like Return Of The Jedi and the PT more than most. There's no crime in it.

I like ROTJ about the same as anyone else (my reference is IMDb score). It is you who likes it less the most. :)

As for the prequels, I don't know where are you got that idea. My signature should be a good clue how much I like the prequels.

I think Bingo's statement is about right. Generally speaking people seem to hold ROTJ in a low/lower regard.

That's why I started this thread. As a ROTJ lover I wanted to know why. I know I like ROTJ "more than most" that's the point.

I love it too. I was just saying if you look at IMDb score, ROTJ is in top 100 all-time. So according to that a lot of people think it is not only good film, but a great film. I don't think you will find a better reference than IMDb to use it for "generally speaking".

Which makes Bingo's statement wrong.