Bingowings said:
That is open to debate but the point I was making is that TPM is much more similar to ROTJ than some people are prepared to confess.
Well and my point was that similarity in concept/design does NOT equal similar quality. Many stuff is similar to (or imitated) Shakespeare's work but yet it does not compare in terms of greatness.
Bingowings said:
What lifts Jedi is the commitment of the lead actor more than anything else.
Well that is your opinion. For me Jedi has a great story, superbly written characters with equally great performances from the actors (Luke, Emperor, Vader, Jerjerrod etc.), the best SFX in OT (or if you look at space battle I could generalise this statement to entire film history), nice location shots, good editing and so on.