Quote
Originally posted by: norinradd
Yes your right the old Emperor did a better job , the old scene had more mystery, the hologram effect just looked better because it wasn't so clear.

Even if you don't care about that, about originality or anything and think the change should be allowed if it's half-decent, I think you'll still be disappointed. We didn't need to "know" how Vader found out who Luke is - nor does the Emperor need to prove he knows, it's just dumbing-down. But the Emperor now looks just like he does in ROTJ for anyone that cares about THAT.