Fang Zei said:

Perhaps it's best to say that Indy IV was more dissapointing as an Indy movie than the prequels were as Star Wars movies, but I would certainly argue the prequels were more dissapointing as movies than Indy IV was as a movie. Spielberg's worst is still better than Lucas.' I wish Steven had directed TPM.

I think it's this. I have two separate rankings for the Star Wars saga, one as Star Wars movies, where RotS somehow topples Empire (Not by much mind you, and it being the first Star Wars movie I saw as a Star Wars fan), and one as movies where Empire shoots RotS, and laughs at its dead corpse.

Actually, I find it fascinating to look back and realize I became a real fan sometime after AotC, presumably because of it, though looking back it is my least favorite. I think the transformative moment that cemented that one day I'd spend time on a message board dedicated to Star Wars was when I made a Lightsaber hilt out of PVC pipe. Also, I loved, and still do love, Kit Fisto. I'm pretty sure at some point in my life, when I can afford to drop a grand on cosplay, I'm gonna do a custom made Kit Fisto costume. God, do I want a Nautolan in Episode VII. Such a cool design. I kinda wanna punch George or whoever decided to botch it up in RotS.