logo Sign In

Post #65112

Author
Rebelscum
Parent topic
AICN's Harry Knowles comments on the 'o4 DVD set
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/65112/action/topic#65112
Date created
18-Sep-2004, 3:32 PM
Why would Lucas add that stupid scream to the ‘97 version, to only remove it again for the ‘04 edition, what´s up with that?? I tell you why - because he doesn´t know what the hell he´s doing anymore - he has lost his vision. I bet he thought that scream was a great idea at the time but then somebody "with their marbles intact" tells him that this change doesn´t make any sense, because Luke chose to fall. Why the hell would he then scream like a scared little baby falling down? And also why would Han Solo not cover his own ass and take Greedo out before he did the opposite, it´s a clear "kill or be killed" situation without doubt in a brutal an unforgiving world of evil Empire domination. This kind of meddling and fiddling is just what Lucas is doing to our beloved OT, he´s making changes just for the sake of it and he doesn´s even know that they will be there in his next "ultimate vision" of those movies, he can´t be sure of those change, that has been proven with the "scream addition/removal". Somebody wiser who Lucas respects just might (and hopefully) come up to him and point out a lot of things that went awfully wrong since the OT versions. Let´s hope he listens, like before. Like when EVERYBODY were disgusted by the loathsome Jar Jar Binks in TPM. What did he do? He made his part in the next one almost non-existent.

peace,

Rebelscum