I would personally like to believe that most people state an honest opinion on what they deem to be a problem, error, continuity issue or simply an edit or cut because of a reason that is given to make it sit better or perhaps work better.

The very real deal here is Ady having to be judge and jury and to decide if what is being said makes sense to him... Or if he sees it totally differently.

Star Wars can be interpreted in so many different ways it can appear muddled when it is in fact not but on the flip side of this it can appear to be fine when it is in fact muddled.