Lord Haseo said:
Ronster said:
We have all seen the films so there is not any surprise left unless it is an edit you don't see coming....
For me the OT is the main part of it for revisited.... Apart from filming a new set of PT movies it is a wreck.....
A prequel story would suffice 1 movie done well in the style of the OTThe surprises being left in are for people who are new to the franchise. I know.....the idea that anyone hasn't seen Star Wars is asinine...I know >_>
There are lot's of people out there that have not seen Star Wars either because it's not what they are interested in or because they just have not seen it yet.
The thing is someone who has not seen Star Wars yet is very unlikely to see a revisited version before seeing the the Special Edition first... Unless like Emanswfan says you introduce it to someone who has not seen it.
So although it is a nice thought Leaving in surprises of what might have been or what should have been in most cases the surprise will have been ruined already unless the story is changed.
But what you are saying about this rings true that the PT had no real twists in the plot...or any attempt of a plot twist was so poorly executed you could see it coming from a mile away and then it just happened and... I was like "yeah, I knew that"
As for Luke's Noooo! Nooo! my response to you is