I understand that and I agree.... My point was that they spoke quite a lot in ANH esb they really did not speak at all and then in Jedi that start talking again....

I was merely trying to say a subtle reminder of what they were and are to become again would connect the dots

i.e. beings that react and that have a voice without sounding cheap and as you quite rightly put across not spouting crap.... But something rather than nothing and done tastefully could make them atleast feel a bit more like they were in ANH.

Or do you think the storm troopers are the best in empire the ones that do not talk?

Look it is not a big deal to me it is just an abservation the best storm troopers are undoubtably in a new hope are they not?