Putting it to a vote is a silly thing to do.

Ady can do what he likes. ESB:R isn't going to be any worse if it's the Executor rather than a normal SD.
As I said, I can see it going either way, but even if it was intended to be Executor, it was done poorly. And making the tower ever so slightly blue not only doesn't really fix any issues with the scene, it just raises more questions. It just doesn't seem to be in Ady's nature to purposely exacerbate a problem with a scene/shot in Star Wars.