Composting real models into a film digitally gives much more amazing results than the composting of 30 years ago. I like how Ady is giving us a good mix of CGI, models, and what was there already. You still feel like you're watching Star Wars, it's just more refreshing.
I never knocked the Special Editions for making changes, it's the fact that they slapped in crap, and ignore some of the more important things that needed fixing. Ady is doing these things, and he isn't sticking in shit, just because he can.The films are maintaining their integrity.
Would be kinda fun to do a "Special Edition" ROTS fanedit just for Lucas and mail it to him.
You could add in Ewoks line dancing across the screen when Anakin is pledging himself to Palpatine,
add in General Grievous firing first at Obi-Wan.
add Jar-Jar into the back of Padme's death scene going "Youssa gonna die?"
Maybe then he'd get why we all have a problem with this kind of vandalism of the OT.