logo Sign In

Post #640348

Author
Flexicon9
Parent topic
Upscaling Robocop Criterion (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/640348/action/topic#640348
Date created
21-May-2013, 7:05 PM

I purchased the Criterion DVD when it was released years ago and still have it... after watching it recently I decided to look around for HD options, already aware from reviews that the various Blu-ray releases have been somewhat underwhelming.  The MGM HD Channel aired what they referred to as "the world premiere of the director's cut" (their language - I know he just considers it the MPAA unrated version) and it was okay looking but not great.  Was it really the 'world premiere'?  I don't know... thought the unrated version had been around for years.  Maybe this was the first HDTV broadcast of the unrated cut?  Okay it was HD yes, but not that impressive.  Then I found a hybrid of the recalled Sony Blu-ray and an HDTV broadcast of the unrated version.  I have to say the clarity and overall color timing was much, much better than the MGM HD broadcast.  Some guy put it together and it's the best HD Robocop I know of so far.  The audio track was strong and it even included the director's commentary.  It's definitely a quality project and worth a look.

(his notes:  The majority of this project utilizes the theatrical Sony Blu-ray as the main source with additional uncut sequences from an HDTV broadcast being spliced in where necessary... the DTS track was taken from the MGM Blu-ray and the commentary is from the Criterion DVD.  Grain has been added to the HDTV source sequences to achieve visual parity to the Sony Blu-ray.)