Ronster said:

When Adywan blew Jah Jah to smitherines on Alderaan in the deleted scenes he clearly expressed a desire... I am only seeking to nurture and develop that desire further.

I pretty sure the scene was more about extending the destruction of Alderaan than showing Jar-jar die. I'm relieved Ady decided not to put it there (for other reasons though). But frankly, if that scene with Jar-jar in it had ended up in the edit it would have ruined it.

You can't just keep saying things like "one of the worst things about the PT is Jar-jar binks" and then find room for him in the OT. I hope you see the contradiction as clearly as I do.

Don't get me wrong. Jar-jar annoys me as much as the next guy but I find all the hatred toward him and "I hope we see him die in a horrible fashion" going a little too far. I know it's Star Wars and it makes us passionate but still...