That list of "50 reasons..." was brought up by Harmy because someone wanted to know what some people didn't like about ROTJ besides the ewoks and Fetts goofy death. I made a fairly large post de-bunking and defending the film against some of those "50 reasons..".

darth_ender said:
ROTJ is a good movie in my mind. I don't mind others disagreeing, and I see flaws with it as well, but I still love it. Opinions can differ from person to person, and we are not all idiots simply because we don't all think alike. I get really tired of people who tell me I'm stupid for enjoying ROTJ, or even for enjoying the PT

Nobody over there called anybody "stupid" or suggested anyone was a "idiot" for liking ROTJ.