logo Sign In

Post #63556

Author
ChainsawAsh
Parent topic
STAR WARS: The Torrents thread
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/63556/action/topic#63556
Date created
12-Sep-2004, 2:02 AM
Hmm... think you could bump Clone War up to the 18th? Anyway awesome editing, Magnolia, and of course Rik, you're awesome for letting this out for free. That really is a huge improvement over TPM, however no amount of editing can ever make that film "good" to me. But at least this is adequately passable compared to TPM (which was shit). Again, no offense whatsoever to Magnolia, he did an amazing job, it is a problem in the source material entirely.

One complaint: how many "Hell's," "Bastards" and "Shits" were you planning on inserting into a Star Wars movie? That one film had more swearing than the entire OT! And all by, of all creatures, Jar Jar! I don't mind the first two as much, but JJ's "Oh shit! Oh shit! Oh shit!" during the Battle of Naboo was a little much for me. Not that I mind swearing, Pulp Fiction and Scarface were fuckin' awesome, but not in a Star Wars movie...

--edit--

Oh, and is your torrent of Clone War going to have the corrected opening crawl? I heard the original (Magnolia's original, that is) spelled a word as "seceed" when it should be "secede" and I also heard he made a new version which corrects this. Is that the one you have or not?