logo Sign In

Post #631261

Author
xhonzi
Parent topic
Religion
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/631261/action/topic#631261
Date created
3-Apr-2013, 10:58 AM

Puggo - Jar Jar's Yoda said:

I was in the BofA scholarship regional finals, which is (or at least was, back then) a debate-style panel with the other dozen or so contestants.  We were given a question to debate, and when I saw it, I knew right away that most of the others would be arguing for a particular point that I happened also to believe in.  I made a conscious decision to argue the other side, even though I didn't believe in what I was arguing for.  The debate ended up being everyone versus me, and since I held my own, I stood out and thus emerged the winner.  That's the only time in my life that I have done that... it felt really risky, but I'm guessing that's what politicians do all the time.

I did the same thing in debate.  I grew up in a very homogeneous area, and there was always a side that no one really wanted to take up.  I took pride in being able to debate positions I didn't believe, because it was then raw debate with personal feelings off the table.  Some people debate very emotionally and I've never seen that work (except for maybe my wife).

I won most of my debates (then, not now), and a few people would come up and tell me how I changed their opinions.  That felt kind of terrible.  I told them I didn't actually like the side I debated, but I'm not sure that mattered.

As you said, it's given me a distaste for lawyers and politicians and the desire to never be one.