In terms of Adywan's edit being the SE we should have had, I don't think anyone can argue with this as it actually has LESS changes than the official SE and addresses many of the official SE's excesses. Ady's version is somewhere in between an enhanced and remastered Theatrical version and George's butchered SE. I fail to see how this is a bad thing.

From a Purist standpoint, the Revisited saga is NOT a preservation, so people need to stop using these tired old arguments against the changes. If you want a preservation, watch the GOUT, or Harmy's or one of a number of other preservations. We can all agree that Ady's edits are preserving more than any official version in existence as it's restoring many things back to how they were in the original release - things we can no longer see in an official Blu Ray release due to George's insistance upon suppressing the Original Unaltered Trilogy.

I'm not sure if Joral's comments were intended to be inflammatory or trolling. His post does seem to be one big Straw Man argument though as his points hinge on Adywan having completely opposite goals to what he's actually trying to achieve.