- Time
- Post link
Joral said:
I know a lot of people will get upset over my opinion, but I just think this is a very flawed fan edit. The changes, in my opinion, are even worse than what George Lucas did with special editions.
Oh, look. Now there's gajillion more ships flying all around Death Star which is now in orbit of some planet for some reason.
Oh, look. Now there's gajillion more snowspeeders and gajillion more walkers.
Oh, look, now there's music during Obi-Wan VS Darth Vader... that sticks out like a sore thumb, much like Darth Vader's "NOOOOoooo" added in third SE o ROTJ.
And so on and on.
Yet edits by Lucas are met with well deserved criticism while there's a lot of praise for this, dare I say, butchery of worse magnitude?
It's clear you don't understand what Lucas actually did. The changes aren't the problem. The erasing of history is the problem.