Joral: There's praise for this fan edit because it's the SE-done-right.

George's edits were randomly chosen, tasteless, and poorly implemented.

Examples:

1. randomly chosen: Reduction of matte lines in one shot, but not in the next shot. This inconsistent "modernization" is all over the SEs.

2. tasteless: Rocks in front of R2-D2... 'nuff said.

3. poorly implemented: Look at the messy colors of the 2004 DVD. Look at the terrible Jabba scene in ANH SE. I can go on and on with this one, but you get the point.

Adywan's edits are not like this at all. I invite you to prove me wrong, but please try to form a coherent argument against them, OK? ;)