logo Sign In

Post #623908

Author
Trooperman
Parent topic
What's the status of the Originals? (the theatrical cuts of the Original Trilogy)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/623908/action/topic#623908
Date created
24-Feb-2013, 12:18 PM

This is why I believe the true version of a film SHOULD be the 4th generation theatrical print, because that is the version everybody saw and THAT is the format that everything, from the cinematography to the special effects work, was intended for. 

Plus, 4th generation negative although it may have the same resolution as a DVD or similar, looks nothing like a DVD blowup (looks much better, more contrasty, different grain structure). 

It is a disservice to old movies to display them from the O-neg where you can see wires on the ships, matte boxes, etc.  It's not just because they were "old" that you see these things- if the o-neg was the final viewing format, those directors back in the day would have found the effects just as off-putting as we do!