mrbenja0618 said:

Michaeldor said:

My storyline for C-3PO in TPM was:

1) He's on Trade Federation ship, everything is the same until...

2) In the scene, where Nute Gunray landed in Theed and says "ah, victory!" I imagined there would be perfect place to put TC (or 3PO). Now, he's appointed by Gunray to accompany the queen.

3) Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan free the queen with her handmaidens and 3PO goes with them to Tatooine and Coruscant.

In conclusion, at the end of TPM Trade Federation is defeated, Maul is dead, and C-3PO serves now Padme.

The idea of Trade Federation 3PO would be good if you redub Gunray with alien voice. He would translate Gunray's lines to Amidala and the rest of the Naboo folk.

By the way, hilts of Obi-Wan's TPM lightsaber is almost the same as Qui-Gons. The only difference are the little spikes at the end of Kenobi's hilt.

I appreciate your passion for a truly great character, but to me these movies already have way too much fan service as is. The only character I feel should be in the prequels is R2. R2 in A New Hope seems to already understand how to get around on Tattooine as 3P0 is lost. And I know they had that convenient scene in ROTS where he gets his memory erased, but I never understood why they didn't do the same with R2. Just dumb.

We already have R2, Jabba, Chewbacca, Greedo (in a cut scene) and I just read an article that a young Han Solo was originally supposed to be featured in ROTS in a scene WITH YODA!

My problem is that with all these little winks and nods to the other films, it makes a galaxy that's supposed to be vast seem a lot smaller.

Long story, short (Too late?) I think Aalenfae is on the right path thus far.

I definitely disagree. An original premise of SW was that it's told from the point of view of the little people, the droids, much like Hidden Fortress (at least, I think that's the source). Getting 3PO in at the beginning and having him serve the Queen thanks to the Federation hijinks allows for the Threeio/Artoo team to be formed in the first film (instead of forming, being broken up, re-forming, stupid battle jokes, etc) and removes the terrible Ani-built-him stuff. It's not a wink/nod; it's preserving a central theme/quality of the saga.

A wink/nod is Boba Fett at Mos Eisley.