Possessed said:

I find it hilarious that you guys put that much thought into whether a puppet is creepy or crappy, and I find it even more funny that anybody would prefer an inconsistency with the rest of the trilogy.

You're still taking our posts seriously?

The whole CPY thing sprouted up when it was suggested that TPM was so bad that it was not only unfixable, but that the lousy stuff (Jar Jar, creepy Yoda, etc.) are all that keep it from being just boring, like watching a train wreck ("at least it sucks", I think were the words I used). Since then, the creepy puppet has acquired a sort of cult status among a few of us (I can't remember who came up with the acronym - wasn't me).

Save Creepy Puppet Yoda!! :)