Puggo - Jar Jar's Yoda said:
I like it! I'd wear a shirt like that, especially if it had a picture of CPY on it.
But CPY isn't an inconsistency... CPY is awesome. An inconsistency is Anakin telling a senator that he just killed an entire village, and the senator not having him arrested immediately. It would be like the Newtown kid showing up at City Hall and the mayor saying "oh, that's ok, it's human to get mad now and then".
That scene always really bothered me. Not that she isn't arresting him, but that she doesn't react at all. She goes straight to "oh, poor baby, murdering all those tuskens must have been so hard on you".
I think it could have been a really powerful scene if she reacted adversely to it at first but then came around to realizing that she loved him, and that he knew it was wrong to do. Thereby forgiving him and keeping it secret.