logo Sign In

Post #617239

Author
pittrek
Parent topic
Rick McCallum Exits Lucasfilm!
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/617239/action/topic#617239
Date created
31-Dec-2012, 7:57 AM

I'm quite shocked by one thing - he wants to do a movie about the Masin brothers. About thieves and mass murderers. And from the description it sounds like he considers them to be heroes :-(

Zombie - yes, you're the only one. Roddenberry's death was a huge tragedy for the franchise. TOS seasons 1-2 - while he was actively involved - were brilliant. Season 3 - Roddenberry left - sucked. TNG season 1-4 - when Roddenberry was heavily involved in it - were great (even when there were many weak episodes). Season 5 - where Roddenberry wasn't involved at all because of his health status, and later his death - and Season 6 were much weaker, but still good, Season 7 was boring (only the finale was brilliant).

Berman's series were anything from boring (DS9 before the Dominion war), through piece of shit (Voyager). The only seasons which I liked from his series were DS9 after the Dominion war started, and the first season of Enterprise.