bkev said:

I thought that 3D BDs would downscale automatically on non-3D TVs, is that not the case?

The BatB 3D BD is 3D only. You have to rip and extract the left-eye stream.

nirbateman said:

I think that if you use the Bluray ripper option on DVDFab, you don't need to extract a single file, it will rip a proper 2D image.

You might be right. I used AnyDVDHD and eac3to.

Also, I've compared the 3D Bluray to the LD rip made by Molly, and even though the video is better than the 2D Bluray, it still doesn't come close to matching the original colors, everything is too bright and the characters still seem out of place.

I agree that the original colors are the best, but I can happily watch the film with the 3D BD's colors. I like it as a new look, whereas I can't stand the previous color timing: it's far too red.

Where do I find the LD rip?