logo Sign In

Harmy's STAR WARS Despecialized Edition HD - V2.7 - MKV (Released) — Page 291

Author
Time

Harmy said:

No matter what I try, no matter what codec I use, I keep getting these rendering errors when rendering AVI.

I hate the ghost in the machine. Hope you can excise yours without too much trouble.

This may be the oft-cited monitor calibration issue, but v.2.1 seems too strong orange-hued. I hadn't watched much through v.2.0 development, but it here seems weaker with some hue-steps off in the other direction. Like Goldilocks and the Three Bears' porridge, overlapping the two seems just about right:

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Although i am a little confused at this point how this scene in the original looked, the overlapped version does look good to me, very interesting.

Author
Time

Hmm, I don't know. I think that blend still has its own issues. Bit of greenish still there, which he tried very hard to look out for and get rid of.

Hard to tell in context of one frame. Aside from a possible difference in monitor, and the interpretations of it, the aim is still for what the film looked like, minor imperfections included, using his best estimations, his eyes, and (probably) his "gut feeling" (aka - "the force") where he wants ;)

It has to be difficult to balance that with the source starting out at such a "crushed" level, designed for over-brightened playback.

Either way, I still like the latest changes. Much nicer than the 2.0 take on this scene.


Author
Time
 (Edited)

I didn't really try to eliminate the green. There's actually still plenty of it and rightly so. I just decided to use the LPP print as a color reference here instead of the IB print, because it looks closer to what I also saw on some 8mm prints, so it was probably what it looked like on the more wide spread versions and also because I like it better. Though I made it all a little brighter than in the LPP transfer that I saw, as I believe it probably should be, plus it's really bright on the IB print, so with brightness I stuck to the IB as a reference, since that was scanned on professional equipment.

Author
Time

Harmy: Do you use any automatic color-matching tools? If so, which ones?

A picture is worth a thousand words. Post 102 is worth more.

I’m late to the party, but I think this is the best song. Enjoy!

—Teams Jetrell Fo 1, Jetrell Fo 2, and Jetrell Fo 3

Author
Time

Harmy said:

No.

Damn! I was hoping you knew of some proprietary and/or commercial color-matching magic.

A picture is worth a thousand words. Post 102 is worth more.

I’m late to the party, but I think this is the best song. Enjoy!

—Teams Jetrell Fo 1, Jetrell Fo 2, and Jetrell Fo 3

Author
Time

Harmy said:

I just decided to use the LPP print as a color reference here instead of the IB print, because it looks closer to what I also saw on some 8mm prints, so it was probably what it looked like on the more wide spread versions and also because I like it better. Though I made it all a little brighter than in the LPP transfer that I saw, as I believe it probably should be, plus it's really bright on the IB print, so with brightness I stuck to the IB as a reference, since that was scanned on professional equipment.

I suspected that's how you came up with the most recent look, and I think it's a good approach and produced good results.

Project Threepio (Star Wars OOT subtitles)

Author
Time

I still haven't made the time to catch up on this thread (premier last night, which was supposed to be the allotted time, whoops...). But I like the new colors for the Ben scene.

“I find your lack of faith disturbing.”

Author
Time

Spaced Ranger said:

Harmy said:

No matter what I try, no matter what codec I use, I keep getting these rendering errors when rendering AVI.

I hate the ghost in the machine. Hope you can excise yours without too much trouble.

This may be the oft-cited monitor calibration issue, but v.2.1 seems too strong orange-hued. I hadn't watched much through v.2.0 development, but it here seems weaker with some hue-steps off in the other direction. Like Goldilocks and the Three Bears' porridge, overlapping the two seems just about right:

Very nice.

I love everybody. Lets all smoke some reefer and chill. Hug and kisses for everybody.

Author
Time

I don't know, the logo in the lower left corner needs some work.

Author
Time

Where did I put my Aloe Vera?

I love everybody. Lets all smoke some reefer and chill. Hug and kisses for everybody.

Author
Time

Hey does anyone, including Harmy, know what the font is that's used for the 'Despecialized Edition' title in the picture from the first post?

Author
Time
 (Edited)

AntcuFaalb said:

Harmy said:

No.

Damn! I was hoping you knew of some proprietary and/or commercial color-matching magic.

I've spent a lot of time searching for Windows-based software capable of histogram matching (video) and haven't had a lot of luck.

MatchGrade available for NukeX, Avid DS and Final Cut Pro seems very good but probably not much help to you unless you have a Mac.

If you search around the net, there are many interesting papers proposing methods for matching colours between (mostly) static images and I think if you had some scripting ability, and could also translate the math, you could achieve excellent results with video. More so in this case as you'd be matching frame-for-frame and the distribution of colour between the sources would be very similar even if the colours themselves are different.

Author
Time

@snicker: There is an avisynth plugin called HistogramAdjust, which can adjust a video using another video as reference, but I've tried it on some various clips and the result never comes out perfect, and it only seems to adjust the RGB gamma curve together, not separately.

So far, Colourlike is the best plugin I know for this, but I wish it would have a mode for video and not only stills. Right now to get the most out of Colourlike, one has to split a video shot by shot and then let it analyze each shot from each version and re-color them separately. There's gotta be somebody with enough coding talent to write an updated plugin based on this.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Thanks, You_Too. I remember reading about the experiments with ColorLike and the results being hit-and-miss. Disappointing, but as you say, there has to be someone out there with the skills to modify the script to compare frames in a video sequence and match individual RGB channels.

Did you test ColorLike with a raw Blu capture? If so, the Blu-ray clipping would play havoc with an automated process and maybe more so with one that operates on combined RGB. Did you notice whether scenes with minimal clipping produced better results? The Blu-ray colour clipping can be easily fixed to test if this is the case.

Another option would be to create an image sequence from the Blu-ray capture and colour match (a reference set) in Photoshop. Perhaps the colour matching algorithm used by Photoshop would offer up more consistent results.

 

Author
Time
 (Edited)

This was related to colormatching discussion, and not Harmy's thread. I'll take it to PMs.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

@g-force: Very interesting script! I'll make sure to try that out.

EDIT: I tried it right now, since I have frame-synched ANH 97 SE to the 2004 SE it was the perfect test-candidate. It looked like it worked quite well, except I noticed in lots of parts the script raised the black level.

So is there any way for you to change the script so the black and white levels are locked in place but the colors are still changed?

Author
Time

I don't want to spoil your fun guys but since I have no intention of using any such scripts, could you find a different place to discuss it? Thanks :-)

Author
Time

Haha sorry! Maybe g-force could start a thread about it.

Author
Time

No need to apologize, I'm sure I collaborated on derailing many a thread myself :-)

Author
Time

hey- i've been trying to get ahold of the despecialized editions that harmy has done so i can properly introduce my 7 year old son to star wars. 

damned george lucas has tipped my hand  by seling to disney, and with them planning a new one they will start showing up on the little tykes radar sooner rather than later. 

Me and my wife had a laugh when we realized we have put more thought and effort into protecting him from the new special edition versions than we had put into protecting him from hard drugs and strangers!

Thing is, we've only got standard definition here at my house, but i am having one hell of a time finding ay of the despecialized editions as non blue-ray versions. I even tried to message the user mentioned in the version 1 release threads as having generated them, but he says he put them up on usenet as binaries months ago and i've been unable to track them down via that route.  I'm ok with having to fiddle a bit to master and burn them, but down converting to NTSC and making sure i get a all the file formats and settings right seems a bit daunting.

if you could help me get my son introduced properly, i'd be very grateful.

 

Rob Hodge

Jedi Knights Scooter Club

Author
Time

I'm terribly sorry if this has already been covered somewhere on the 7300ish post on this thread but I would be grateful if there were MKV versions of these projects.

Recently a friend of mine uncovered one of that rare breed (someone who has never seen Star Wars) and he wanted to show her the films as close to how he encountered them and asked me if I had something better than GOUT.

I brought my copies of the Disc images over as they play ok on my Mac.

They wouldn't play on his PC or his media player.

They don't play on my media player without the fore-mentioned stutter as the player tries to keep time and failing.

The MKV format plays on just about anything these days and doesn't require burning to disc.

If Harmy is too busy to do it himself I would be very grateful to any boffin willing to give it a go as these projects are the best representation of the original versions currently available.