muddyknees2000 said:

Bingowings said:

I think it's insane that old continuity issues, for example, are not addressed in even the latest official SE but new ones have been introduced (Artoo's appearing/vanishing natural alcove etc).

Try explaining this to someone accusing you of hypocrisy for preferring Ady's changes to Lucas'. A bad change, consistently applied, is better than even the greatest addition/alteration that is only applied to one shot thus creating all new continuity errors.

The people who criticize us fans of ady for being hypocritical are failing to understand a basic fact.

If you are going to do something then do it right (great expression). This notion holds true for GL as well. If you are going to make changes do them right or don't bother. For example, GL failing to make Luke's saber consistently blue on the falcon in ANH is a clear sign that he and ILM simply don't give a f***.

Contrast that with zillions of Ady's subtle, yet HIGH quality & consistent tweaks and fixes and maybe they'll see why we prefer Ady's take over GL's.

I'm a SE fan and an OT fan, I simply wish GL had cared enough to release BOTH versions in as high quality as possible. Instead he half-assed the SE and abandoned the OT.

That aside - (yet on the same subject) - it's cool to hear Ady fixed that ESB jump-cut.