Puggo - Jar Jar's Yoda said:

This is why I consider fan-edit efforts to make the prequels total failures... the prequels are only worth watching in their original, hideous form. Because at least they can then be enjoyed for their humor factor. Remove the humor and they're just dull.

The design work is very good at times, some of the plot elements (the ones that make sense) are valid and in keeping with the series.

There is even a few nice performance moments hidden in there.

The score is almost perfect.

I think a good fan edit of the prequel trilogy (and Return Of The Jedi) can be done.

They will never be as good as the first two films but they can be made to make sense and flow as stories.

They need more work than just cutting lines out though and not everyone has the resources to do that.

Frink has made the films much more watchable in the opposite direction.