To answer the initial question; Think I've always been. I remember seeing the SE at the local cinema thinking "This doesn't sound or look right" about all three. Even though I did think that the additions to the final ANH battle was kind of cool, it ended up as a "meh" in my mind. And I kind of had that feeling confirmed when I bought the WS VHS set. So up until the DVDs came out I stuck to my original widescreen editions of the trilogy and the SE just sat there collecting dust.

And then we got the GOUT and all, and I discovered OT - forums and well, here I am, purist to the heart. And a fan of fan edits ;)
Cheers all!