ROTJ, in spite of its flaws, really appeals to me as well. Of all the films, it has long been the most fun in my mind. Now, with a more analytical understanding of life, ESB has really grown on me, while it used to be my least favorite. I think ROTJ has more weak moments, but it also has the strongest IMO. I honestly get a bit choked up watching a silent (key word) Vader looking back at forth between his son and his master, deciding whose side he's on. It's very powerful to me and ties everything together nicely. I have my own ideas for changes, and I really am excited to see a Revisited version, but nevertheless, I think it's a great film.