logo Sign In

Post #607822

Author
LexX
Parent topic
Who should Direct the Star Wars VII, VIII, and IX ?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/607822/action/topic#607822
Date created
15-Nov-2012, 1:20 PM

Tyrphanax said:

LexX said:

Bester said:

Because....

Too long, not funny, bad plot, unlikeable characters...

I don't remember the book being too funny...

Who's talking about the book? I thought we were talking about the movies. The film tries to be funny way too much with stupid one-liners and fails to deliver. Haven't seen it lately for a good reason so don't remember exactly. Ian was a good sidekick in the first film to have some good comments but he isn't good as a lead character. Also "his kid" is annoying as hell unlike the kids in the first film.

BmB said:

Too long? What kind of complain is that?

Bad plot? What, are you kidding? The InGen takeover is probably an even better plot than the first one. And this really gets into why JP3 is bad, atrocious effects aside, Spielberg insisted the animals never be made the villian because they're just animals. And he's right. Who's the bad guy in JP? Dennis maybe, the god of chaos willing that shit hits the fan. Who's the bad guy in TLW? Even easier, you've got Hammond's nephew, arguably the hunter guy doing stupid things.

Who's the bad guy in JP3? Yeah that's right the bloody lame spinosaur. It has no plot other than rargh, bad CGI dinos eat you!!! Wild animals bad! Rargh!

A fair one? If a movie drags too long, it's a negative. The same way it's a complain, that JPIII is way too short (but that's probably for the best giving the content).

Yes, the plot in TLW is ridiculous. I don't need a bad guy to make the film good or bad so what kind of comment is that anyways. And I agree about JPIII.

Anyways, on topic maybe.