Bizzle. Welcome to the boards. You are certainly more knowledgable of the trilogy than I am, and I have seen them a 100 times. But, I got to say...what's up with hammering Magnolia? If you don't like his edits, don't watch them. Seriously. And if you've never seen them before, watch them before you criticize. He spent alot of time and put a lot of thought in to these. That is worth merit. And he has given them to us...free. FREE. A LOT OF THOUGHT AND FREE. Two things that do not register with GL these days. I don't agree with everything he did. But no one will. Everyone would do something a little different, especially when the source material is soooo tainted (TPM ESPECIALLY). Like the edits or not, respect him and his efforts. Its another great edition to my collection and certainly, I feel a vast improvement on Episode I and II. I hated Ep. I sooo much, and now with his edit its more than tolerable (I would still like to see less of the CG characters and have Jar Jar's tone of voice changed...though doing the alien voices was brilliant and effective). Episode II went from decent to awesome with his edit (again I might drop the scene with the obnoxious child figuring out the planet being missing and somehow use the scene in the library shorter with different dialogue and drop Dex's scene for the deleted scene with the droids and change the droids to saying they identified it...I hate obnoxoius kids and stupid CG though). ALLLLL of this said. My point is, I may do something slightly different. But I didn't and have neither the time nor the knowledge nor the ability. The fact is, flat out, these are better than what George gave us. And check this. All that work, all that time. He sent them to me (shipping, burning, DVDs) FREE. What edits have you made bizzle? Send them to me. Until then respect him and what he gave us.