logo Sign In

Post #607560

Author
angryboy
Parent topic
Harmy's STAR WARS Despecialized Edition HD - V2.7 - MKV (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/607560/action/topic#607560
Date created
14-Nov-2012, 5:21 AM

Hi Harmy,

I wanted to first echo the post from a couple of pages back congratulating you on the fantastic job you're doing (and have already done) here. I finally watched the trilogy for the first time in a long time without cringing at all the changes that have been made and I was finally able to share these movies with my wife. With a child on the way, I expect that your versions will be the ones that I share with him when he's old enough as well.

Now for some minor feedback:

- If at all possible, PLEASE keep future releases as .mkv formats. The .m2ts files in the ACVHD package caused me no end of trouble because I needed to play them with subtitles and VLC doesn't like putting subs up when .m2ts files are playing. I know, it's my fault for getting a mac... I ended up watching both ESB and RotJ on a six-year-old laptop running Windows XP.

- Your cleanups of the special effects are tremendous. My wife noticed nothing, my friend noticed nothing, only by paying careful attention was I able to spot elements that felt "not quite right". I'm sure you've already got your hands full with your plans for continuing improvements, but if I could suggest the following scenes as deserving of extra attention...

[Edited as per suggestion below]

Sorry for posting about RotJ in a thread about SW.

Again, awesome work, Harmy. Thank you for all your hard work!