I have the Three DVD Collection of Brotherhood of the Wolf. It inserts previously deleted scenes from the theatrical release into the movie. My wife enjoyed the extras, but I thought it dragged out the movie even more and weren't needed. As for the discs themselves, the collection is great, and would be ideal for re-editing.

I *loved* the theatrical release.

It's kind of like the deleted scenes they added back in in the Extreme DVD version of Terminator 2. I'm glad the second disc has the theatrical cut in HD, because I wasn't impressed with most of the inserted things they put on the first disc. (Teaching the Terminator to tell a joke?!? Ummm... okay.)