I'm not saying theres anything wrong with the CGI (apart from there being way too damn much of it in the film)....just that the specific visual gag they used to reveal the battle is not consistant with a SW film.

I'd agree with Bingo that the effects in ROTS were alot more even....AOTC had ups and downs that made things stick out more. Though theres things I still notice.......Commander Cody for instance....the scene where Obi rides up and Cody gives him back his lightsaber....Temura's head just never seems right on that CGI clone trooper's body. Though ROTS was just so completely CGI filled that it really comes off as more of a video game than a film.....with AOTC as a close second.