logo Sign In

Post #598840

Author
Puggo - Jar Jar's Yoda
Parent topic
GOUT Bugs (and DUDSbtEoEE)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/598840/action/topic#598840
Date created
27-Sep-2012, 6:28 PM

I do consider the non-anamorphic format to be a bug.  Why?  Because industry standard at the time was to release widescreen movies anamorphically. It shouldn't have been necessary to state that it was anamorphic; a reasonable presumption is that it would be.  It's also the first thing that fan edits correct when using GOUT as a base - something LFL should have done from the start. So it is obviously for all practical purposes a bug that should have, and could at zero cost have been, fixed.

If a DVD of Wizard of Oz came out and it turned out to be black and white, would it not be a mistake because the label didn't say "in color"?  No, certain things are just presumed.  If it skips, would it not be a mistake because the disk didn't say "won't skip"?

Perhaps if the disc included the label - "disclaimer: outdated crappy non-anamorphic f-ed up transfer", then there wouldn't be any bugs!