logo Sign In

Post #588839

Author
cas_tanje
Parent topic
Info & Ideas: ESB and ROTJ Wishlist
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/588839/action/topic#588839
Date created
6-Aug-2012, 11:26 AM

Hi Ady! It's been a long time!

Alright, you're not even nearly done with ESB: R, but I've watched the Bluray version of RotJ and I've made a list of suggestions. I hope you could eventually take a minute to look at these? These suggestions are only for the first 30 minutes so far (before the execution scene), but here they are :) :

  1. 2:00 - New space (more stars, more colors, more eye-candy)
  2. 2:42 - Newer interface for the screen with the Imperial Shuttle. It looks very old, lol.
  3. 5:00 - Could it be possible to restore Luke's saber creation scene?
  4. 5:30 - Can you keep the larger door from the Bluray's version of Jabba's Palace? I like it :)

  5. 6:50 - Add more life to the boar-like creatures (expressions like you did with Yoda? They really look like puppets now lol)
  6. 8:18 - Also more life to the weird lizard/frog/dog-like creature on the floor? (Blinks? More mouth movements when it barks?)
  7. 8:45 - Tweaks for Jabba? Mouth movements?
  8. 10:26 - Also: the weird little mouse lizard could use a little update?

  9. 11:10 - The droid torture machine doesn't really touch the droid's feet. Could the steam also be a little bit more realistic?
  10. 12:30 - Give all the creatures a bit more life during Jabba's party? And please: keep the CGI ones :D I like them!

  11. 18:53 - The red glow while melting Han should cover Han's whole body (Example: Han's hands and hair don't have the glow at the edges
  12. 19:03 - Better placing of Han's face under the carbonite (his mouth is misplaced: too much to the left)
  13. 25:15 - little tweaks to the rancor? :) Though I actually think it's quite realistic!
  14. 27:15 - Don't let Luke try to break the iron bars that much. It looks quite silly for a jedi, lol.
  15. 27:37 - Let Luke use a bit of the force to throw the skull at the switch?
  16. 27:37 - More accurate hit of the switch? Place the skull a bit higher? After all, Luke is a Jedi :)

 

Oh, and before I forget: The following things also bugged me a lot:

  1. Palpatines lightning still looks quite fake to me. Maybe you could make it look a lot better?
  2. The worst and most fake part of the movie for me:
    When Vader decides to throw Palpatine, Luke gets up too quickly as if he doesn't have any pain from the lightning. It's like: "Hey lightning is gone and now I can watch my dad throwing the emperor away, yay!" Maybe you could slow down Luke while he's getting up?

 

These are my suggestions for now :) Sorry for my bad English, and also sorry if this all looks a little bit greedy. I don't mean it that way. I really love your work and I only want to help!

Good luck! You're awesome!