Baronlando said:

Yeah it seems pretty lame. Maybe the star wars schtick is getting into that embarrassing "Old Lucy" phase now. The "Prometheus questions" thing was good though.

I actually think commentaries for the original trilogy are a great idea, sort of an anti-prequel-review thing, explaining why the original trilogy is awesome instead of why the prequels suck. I think he just spent too much time going off on Plinkett-is-creepy tangents instead of explaining what is so perfect about the film. When he focuses on the latter, he nails it and presents a near-flawless analysis.