Yeah, it wasn't very funny, not even remotely as funny as his prequel reviews, but I'm not really a fan of Plinkett and RedLetterMedia for the laughs so much as for the astute film analysis. You can't really fault these guys for that. And with as much reading as I do all day long, I love good film criticism on video (or mp3 in this case).
While it does feel at times like listening to one of your drunk friends try to make a point about something, the commentary has some excellent moments of explaining just what is so perfect about SW77, and he even points out a few plot holes I've never seen anyone else mention before. If you're the kind of guy who watches Star Wars multiple times a year, and you're a fan of Plinkett and RLM, it wouldn't hurt to watch it once with Plinkett's commentary