Greetings everyone.
Just want to contribute to the ROTJ wishlist. Hopefully all you wonderful fan-editors out there (especially Adywan, haha) could consider these ideas (alas, I have no experience in doing edits). I also posted this wishlist in the starwarsrevisited facebook page under the name "ben panced" (which is why Adywan is mentioned in the list):
1. Title crawl: Depends on Adywan (use original or create new crawl)
2. Pan down to Death Star 2.0 orbiting Endor. Hope Adywan could extend this scene to show the Executor and more Star Destroyers & other Imperial ships orbiting the forest moon.
3. Shuttle carrying Vader leaving the Executor heading towards Death Star.
4. Cut: the dialogue btwn control officer and the shuttle (they already know it's Vader on board. Why ask for code?). Just show the shuttle entering and landing.
5. If technologically possible, add more stormtroopers and Imperial personnel welcoming Vader's arrival.
6. Conversation with the Commander.... (what do u guys think, should his line "I need more men" be cut? Just sounds creepy, haha. Just kidding).
7. Biggest Wish #1: Again, if possible, add the deleted scene where Vader enters his chamber and uses the Force to contact and tempt Luke to the Darkside. Then it shows Luke finishing the construction of his new lightsaber.
8. Insert Dagobah/Yoda death scene here. Many have argued over whether to cut Yoda's confirmation that Vader is Luke's father as well as Obi-Wan's scene. Let's just leave that to Adywan. Personally, I would keep those scenes.
9. Show Luke leaving Dagobah.
10. Arrival of Emperor scene. Again, maybe Ady could extend the scene to show more ships.
11. Show Luke approaching Tattooine.
12. Operation Rescue Scruffy Looking Nerf Herder scenes, har har. Show 3P0 & R2 heading towards Jabba's Palace. This next few scenes are a little tricky. A lot has been discussed on how the rescue takes place. Some say that Leia and Chewbacca are already captives of Jabba. Some say keep the original scenes. Others say cut the Rancor scene. I say: Let Adywan decide, har har.
13. Luke arrives at Jabba's Palace. Cut: Luke Force choking the Gamorean guards (very Darksidey). Go straight to Luke Mind-Tricking Bib Fortuna. Again, depends on Adywan as to what takes place from here on.
14. Sail Barge scenes. Agree with Adywan, give Boba Fett a better and awesome death scene.
15. Cut: Falcon and X-Wing splitting up and Luke telling R2 they're going to Dagobah.
16. Biggest Wish #2: Maybe Adywan could create a new scence showing Luke and Gang arriving at the Rebel fleet "massing near Sullust". Would really love to see Ady include the planet and Rebel fleet.
17. Rebel Briefing Scene. Probably could bring forward the scene where Luke enters (without saying "I'm with you too") and hugs Leia and she asks him "What's wrong?/Ask again sometime". Greets Han & Chewie. For me this makes more sense as this is the first time they meet up together after the rescue.
18. Briefing by Mon Mothma, Admiral Ackbar and General Nadine...sorry...Madine.
19. Agree with others to cut Han's more cheesy/corny lines.
20. Han & Lando scene: Definitely need to alter the background. Maybe Ady could also improve/extend the view of the hangar bay. Cut: Han's "I want you to take her. I mean in take her. You need all the help u can get she's the fastest ship in the fleet." Go straight to Lando's "All right ol' buddy, I know what she means to you......." so that we jump to the middle of their conversation.
21. Show them leaving the fleet (probably have them fly past several cruisers, just to show more of the Rebel fleet) and then jump to hyperspace.
22. CUT: Vader and Palp scene: "Send the fleet to the far side of Endor........." until the end of the scene.
23. CUT: Whole shuttle approach scene. I always felt that this scene didn't seem logical. If they "stole" the shuttle don't you think the Imperials could scan & identify it despite its 'disguise'. Not to mention using an "older code". Besides, why would they choose a direct approach to get to the shield generator?
24. Biggest Wish #3: If possible, Adywan could instead create a scene which shows the shuttle coming out of lightspeed & sneaking into Endor from the other side/far side. That's why I suggested cutting the the scene in no.22 above. Of course cutting the original shuttle approach scene would also affect the whole Luke sensing Vader, Vader sensing Luke thing, but I'm sure it could be re-worked in another way or in another scene.
25. Move CUT scene no.22 here. Reason: the Emperor is of course aware that the Rebels have sneaked into Endor (he let them). Now the Emperor sets his plans into motion by moving the fleet to the far side of Endor as a trap for the Rebel fleet. And since Luke & Co sneaked in "before" the Imperial fleet moved to the far side, they are also not aware of the impending trap for the Rebel fleet.
25a. Biggest Wish #4: Now comes the tricky part: Mixing and re-working this scene with the scene where Vader informs the Emp that a small Rebel force has landed on Endor....his son is with them.....blah blah blah. My suggestion for this scene:
Vader: "What is thy bidding my Master?"
Palp: "Send the fleet to the far side of Endor. There it will stay until called for."
Vader: "A small rebel force has (CUT: ...penetrated the sheild and..) landed on Endor." "My son is with them." (Obviously Vader sensed it because Luke was on board).
Palp: "Yes I know." "Then you must go to the Sanctuary Moon and await him."
Vader: "He will come to me?"
Palp: "I have forseen this. His compassion for you will be his undoing. He will come to you and then you will bring him before me." "Soon the rebellion be will crushed and young Skywalker will be one of us."
(Optional) Vader: "As you wish."
.............to be continued...................