rabscuttle1 said:

I like TPM, but ...

Hold it right there!!

The phone was ringing, I'm back. Now, where were we?

;-)

On topic; I liked the way he was presented in Empire. To me, he worked perfectly as the voice of the past. He lost his mystical, wise old soul feeling in Phantom. The stills I've seen from the last two films look like they just went full-on kids' cartoon for him - flipping around, twirling lightsaber. It would be hard to undo that much damage to the character, even with Zahn at the helm.