aalenfae said:

MrInsaneA:
I'm all for leaving the conditions of Padme's death unknown. You're right. The mystery would make things more interesting.
However, the reason I don't really like The Cutter's idea is just that it's so jarring. I guess because the clip doesn't really... match the cinematographic style of the rest of the shots? But it also might be his musical choice he used. That's why I'm going to experiment with the idea and see how it works. I haven't thrown it out yet.

TavorX:
Thanks for your idea. It certainly does get me thinking, as I've been planning on totally overhauling the dialogue in that scene.

That's wonderful!! New, thoughtful, dialogue should totally create a different, yet better, outlook for that scene!

By the way, I managed to find some rather rare footage (claims to be fan made, not 100% sure) some months ago of ROTS. Here it is http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-iu7dzSyZK4&list=FL1FEzdish9PWbUvT4ytK4VA&index=21&feature=plpp_video

It may be useful to you ;)