muddyknees2000 said:

nope.....my point was...Ady does it well and with consistancy, Lucas just messes everything up and adds new continuity errors.

I had also suggested that people were more critical of the rubber masks in ANH that the ewoks in ROTJ, therefore it makes more sense to animate something that looks a bit fake than something that was more or less fine to begin with.

My first point was that the article went out of it's way to not acknowledge Ady's blinks at all, while mentioning the ewok change to bash Lucas with. They could have at least compared the quality of the blinks, as you've just done, but for anyone who only first discovers ANH:R BECAUSE of the article may assume that blinks = bad change, only to download Ady's edit and realize he also adds blinks. Many people won't concern themselves with the quality, but with the fact that the blinks exist at all, because I've rarely heard anyone praise the ewok blinks, and rarely heard anyone disapprove Ady's added blinks.